On this day in military history…
On 17 November 1942, the German submarine U-331 was sunk in the Mediterranean north-west of Algiers. Almost a year earlier, she had inflicted one of the Royal Navy’s most devastating losses by sinking the battleship HMS Barham. Now her own career ended in a confused series of air attacks, after a white flag had been displayed and a British warship had been sent to capture her.
U-331 was a Type VIIC submarine commanded by Kapitänleutnant Hans-Diedrich von Tiesenhausen. Commissioned in March 1941, she became notorious on 25 November that year when she attacked the British Mediterranean Fleet off the Egyptian coast. Three of her torpedoes struck Barham, which rapidly rolled over before a massive magazine explosion tore through the battleship. The disaster claimed 862 lives.
The extraordinary film of Barham’s destruction captured the terrifying speed with which a capital ship could be lost. For the families of those killed, it was a personal tragedy on an immense scale. For U-331, the attack became the defining success of her wartime service.
On 17 November 1942, RAF Hudson aircraft of No. 500 Squadron attacked U-331 with depth charges and gunfire. Damage left her unable to dive, turning the submarine into an exposed target. Flooding lowered her bows until her propellers were almost clear of the water. Her crew attempted to move stern-first towards the North African coast.
What followed was confused. British aircrew and German survivors gave differing accounts of the sequence of gunfire and surrender signals. A white flag was displayed, and Tiesenhausen said he informed a circling flying boat that he had surrendered. HMS Wilton was dispatched from Algiers to capture the submarine and her crew.
Before Wilton could arrive, aircraft from HMS Formidable attacked. The British interrogation report records that U-331’s diesel engines had been restarted while the white flag remained displayed. A Martlet fighter strafed the boat, wounding Tiesenhausen, before a Fairey Albacore torpedo bomber struck her with a torpedo. The submarine disappeared beneath the surface.
Thirty-two members of U-331’s crew died and 17 survived, including their commander. Survivors were rescued by the flying boat and HMS Wilton. The Albacore belonged to No. 820 Naval Air Squadron, while the attacking Martlets were from No. 893 Naval Air Squadron.
U-331’s loss brought a grim reversal of fortune. The submarine that had destroyed Barham was herself destroyed by aircraft, with a capture attempt already under way. Behind the familiar story of hunter becoming hunted lies a more complicated episode: a damaged submarine, disputed accounts of surrender, and separate British forces converging before the situation had been brought under control.
